AfterReacherandRebel Ridge’s success, it seems possible that even a remake ofClint Eastwood’s spaghetti Western,A Fistful of Dollars, might actually work. Although most details surrounding the upcoming remake ofA Fistful of Dollarsare under the covers, there is already an air of skepticism around it. Many viewers cannot help but believe that the classic Western does not need a remake because it stands the test of time, and remakes, in general, are known to often fall short of capturing the essence of the original.
Given how theDollars Trilogyis often touted as one of the best movie franchises ever created, the remake has the massive responsibility of living up to the high standards set by the original films. Owing to this, it is understandable why many viewers already believeA Fistful of Dollars' remakeis doomed to fail. However, a closer look at modern-day takes onA Fistful of Dollars' “lone wolf” and “mysterious stranger” tropes in shows andmovies likeRebel RidgeandReacherraises hope that the remake could etch its identity in the Western genre.
Reacher & Rebel Ridge Highlight The Enduring Appeal Of Lone Wolf Characters
Both The Show And The Movie Have Been Successful With Their Portrayals Of Modern Lonewolfs
The “lone wolf” trope has probably existed since the earliest days of storytelling, and its origins can likely be traced to ancient myths and legends. However, despite being one of the oldest storytelling devices, especially in the action genre, it still seems to have an undying appeal. This has been proven by the success of modernshows like Amazon’sReacher, which adopts the trope by portraying Jack Reacher as a solitary figure who proudly calls himself a hobo.
Although Terry Richmond and Jack Reacher are unique in more ways than one, they can be seen as echoes of all the lone-wolf characters that have captivated audiences throughout history.
In each new season of the series, Reacher arrives in a new town as a mysterious stranger and serves justice to wrongdoers before fleeing the scene.Rebel Ridge’s Terry Richmond does something similar by standing tall in the face of extreme corruption and injustice. Despite being pressed by the law enforcers of a small town, the character continues to embody resilience and moral conviction. Although Terry Richmond and Jack Reacher are unique in more ways than one, they can be seen as echoes of all the lone-wolf characters that have captivated audiences throughout history.
Rebel Ridge Ending Explained
After walking through a slam-bang showdown between Terry Richmond and the police, Rebel Ridge’s gripping action drama finally ends on a positive note.
Yet, even though they seem familiar,it is hard not to be compelled by their conviction to take down oppression and their courage to stand alone. Even from a critical standpoint, bothRebel RidgeandReacherhave performed incredibly well. WhileRebel Ridgeboasts a Rotten Tomatoes critics score of 96%,Reacherhas averaged a score of 95% across two seasons. Both highlight how audiences would enjoy seeing a new take onA Fistful of Dollars, which is known for portraying one of the most badass lone-wolf characters.
Clint Eastwood’s The Man With No Name Is One Of The Best Lone Wolf Characters In Cinema
He Embodies All The Qualities One Expects To See In Such A Character
Even though Clint Eastwood’s The Man With No Name defies all societal norms, he carries himself with a sense of discipline and resolve that demands respect. Although he lets his actions do most of the talking, his words can be as piercing as the bullets from his gun because he puts immense thought behind everything he says. What makes The Man With No Name all the more intriguing is thathe does not represent the typical morally righteous hero. There is always an air of ambiguity surrounding his morality as he helps the oppressed while also seeking personal gains.
Did You Know:A Fistful of Dollarswas initially titledThe Magnificent Stranger, which was more in tandem with how Clint Eastwood’s The Man With No Name is portrayed in the film. However, the title was changed only a few days before the film’s theatrical release.
With his iconic squinty eyes and cold delivery ofThe Man With No Name’s memorable quotes, Clint Eastwood also creates a striking visual and emotional impact in every sequence from the movie trilogy. Although his dialogue is minimal, he carries himself with a sense of commanding stoicism and charisma that draws all the attention towards him every time he shows up on the screen. As a viewer, it is also hard not to be fascinated by how a character like The Man With No Name epitomizes independence and self-sufficiency by single-handedly taking down formidable enemies.
Reacher & Rebel Ridge Prove It’s A Good Time For A Fistful Of Dollars' Remake
They Prove Audiences Are Ready To See A Contemporary Take On The Spaghetti Western
In many ways,A Fistful of Dollarsis a product of its time. Owing to this, any efforts to recreate it will undoubtedly be risky. However, when it comes to its storytelling structure and thematic explorations of power dynamics, justice, and survival, many successful shows and movies likeRebel RidgeandReacherhave demonstrated that audiences still crave narratives that explore these enduring ideas. If done well,A Fistful of Dollars' remake could hop on the same wave andsatiate the hunger audiences have for witnessing badass, morally ambiguous characters that take down the wealthy, the wicked, and the powerful.
1964
98%
91%
1965
92%
94%
The Good, The Bad and the Ugly
1966
97%
Considering the originalDollars Trilogy’s legacy, the newFistful of Dollarswill likely struggle to be on par with the original, let alone be better. However,Rebel RidgeandReacher’s positive receptionproves that the originalClint Eastwood Western’s themes still hold relevance and can very well be portrayed through a more contemporary lens. They also highlight that even though Clint Eastwood’s iteration of The Man With No Name can never be replaced,A Fistful of Dollars' remake can have its own unique and memorable version of the lone-wolf character.
What The Fistful Of Dollars Remake Can Learn From Modern Lone Wolf Stories Like Reacher & Rebel Ridge
Reacher & Rebel Ridge Offer The Perfect Blueprint For The Fistful Of Dollars' Remake To Succeed
Most remakes of classic movies struggle to leave their mark because they merely try to recreate the age-old formula adopted by their parent films. The remakes that strike the right balance between honoring the legacy of their original movies and finding new ways to present the familiar story are usually successful. Owing to this,A Fistful of Dollars' remake can learn a lot from modern lone-wolf stories like Reacher and Rebel Ridge to defy expectations and prove that not all remakes are destined to fail.
Given how the originalA Fistful of Dollars' is arguably a far better lone-wolf story thanReacherandRebel Ridge, the remake of the classicClint EastwoodWestern has the potential to be even better than most modern takes on the “mysterious stranger” archetype if executed well.
LikeRebel Ridgeriffs on several relatable real-world issues, like civil asset forfeiture and police brutality, theFistful of Dollars' remake could also focus on contemporary social themes while walking through the journey of its Man With No Name.Reacherproves that lone-wolf characters who walk the line between heroism and anti-heroism are still engaging to watch as long as their vigilantism is justified with solid reasoning.
Therefore,A Fistful of Dollars' remake must find a way to portray its version of the Clint Eastwood characterin such a way that he appears both morally ambiguous and relatable like Jack Reacher. Given how the originalA Fistful of Dollarsis arguably a far better lone-wolf story thanReacherandRebel Ridge, the remake of the classicClint EastwoodWestern has the potential to be even better than most modern takes on the “mysterious stranger” archetype if executed well.
A Fistful of Dollars
A Fistful of Dollars is a spaghetti Western film from director Sergio Leone starring Clint Eastwood. A Fistful of Dollars is notable for being Clint Eastwood’s big break in Hollywood and also for being the beginning of the “Dollars Trilogy.” The film was followed by For a Few Dollars More in 1965 and The Good, The Bad and the Ugly in 1966.
Rebel Ridge
Former Marine Terry Richmond travels to Shelby Springs to post bail for his cousin, only to find his savings unjustly seized by a corrupt local police force. With the help of court clerk Summer McBride, Terry uncovers a deep-seated conspiracy and vows to bring justice to the town.
Reacher
Reacher follows Jack Reacher, a former military police investigator, as he navigates civilian life. Without a phone and carrying minimal belongings, Reacher drifts across the country, experiencing the nation he once served, and encounters intriguing challenges along the way.
